I've written this letter a million times a day in my head over the past few days but haven't put pen to paper. I guess I haven't been true to my promise that I'll be open and honest about my feelings. I keep thinking I have something to lose. But really, I don't. So if I appear wreckless, foolish, stupid, or desperate then so be it. It doesn't really matter anymore...
I miss you. I know things are weird between us right now. And that's probably my fault. I have all these insecurities I try to cover up. It's ridiculous how I expected you to be honest about yours when I can't even show you mine. So I've pretended I'm fine. But I'm not.
When I was in high school I had a boyfriend who was my first love. At some point in the relationship, as we neared the last half of senior year, he asked for a bit of space to sort things out in his head. I was broken - I thought that if he wasn't 100% sure, he obviously had never been sure and didn't want to be with me. So I ran full-fledged at the next guy that would take me so I wouldn't have to process the perceived rejection. A week later, my first love came to discuss things with me, and I blew him off, telling him I had moved on. Awhile later I stumbled across his blog, in which he had written a post where he couldn't understand how I could move on so quickly if I truly loved him. It hurt like hell to read those words, to think that's what he thought. That stayed with me for a long time, but somehow faded the more I repeated the action of "moving on" instead of allowing for time to heal. And I thought I had changed, and you and I even discussed that. So I haven't thought about this situation in years...until I woke up this morning at 5:30am and couldn't shake the horrible feeling that I've given you this same impression.
I wish I could just make you a mixtape of every song lyric that I've been listening to for the last few days. Songs are so much more poetic and beautiful than what I have to say. But here goes...
I've taken so personally the times you've needed space and can't figure out what you need. I thought that if you couldn't see 100% that it was me, you never could, never did, and never would. I realize now that logic is skewed. But I felt ridiculous needing you when you didn't seem to also acknowledge that same need. And somehow we kept falling back together. To me, it's because from the moment I met you, it felt like home. And no matter what happens, you can always go home. Maybe that's ridiculous, but it's how I feel.
The thought of you finding somebody else or losing your feelings for me made me panic in the craziest of ways. I felt the goodbye Saturday night when I was driving home. And I imagined all these scenarios in my head this week...and I went into defense mode. I shut off and decided to not process your unspoken rejection and throw myself full-fledged into dating. Monday I met a guy off Tinder. On paper he seemed to be everything I thought I wanted. But even driving to meet him, I didn't want to. I wished you would text me and tell me to come over instead, so we could laugh and I could believe that you actually liked me. But you didn't text. And so I went. And from the moment I met him I just spent the evening wishing he was you. The conversation was polite. The food was adequate. But the magic wasn't there, and I found myself comparing the two of you all evening. When the date ended, he kissed me goodbye at my car. I thought I was going to throw up. I got in my car and sobbed. And called you. You didn't answer. And I cried harder. That night I couldn't sleep because my heart hurt so much.
Tuesday I went out with an old acquanitence from college. When he asked about past relationships, I couldn't even bring myself to speak about you in that way. You weren't a past relationship, you were my present state of mind. And when I got asked why it ended, it hurt to much to even bring myself to process the truth: that you couldn't feel that way about me. And the date was a pleasant distraction from my heartbreak, except the fear that you were on a date, laughing, flirting, comparing her to me wouldn't stop nagging at me. When I got home after the date it was 2am. And I wanted desperately to text you. But I couldn't let you know how much I needed you. So I layed in bed looking at the ceiling. I couldn't cry, I was too sad. So I deleted your number. I deleted your pictures. But I couldn't delete your memories. So I numbed my mind and watched the clock tick by the minutes until I finally fell asleep.
In the morning, I wanted to text you, but I didn't know your number. So I checked Twitter, the only place we still had contact. When you weren't my friend on there, my heart literally plummeted. I searched for your account and my fears were confirmed. He's found somebody else. He isn't interested anymore. I should have broken clean. I should have stuck to my guns. I should have stopped. But instead, I found your number on the texts on my iPad. And I texted you. I have never hated a conversation with you more. I knew I was hurting you. I knew you were hurting me. I knew I should just let you go. So I legitimately tried. I went on a date that night. He and I had exchanged some witty texts. But in person, I wanted to just walk away immediately. It wasn't right. I left shortly after meeting him and felt so hollow. Nobody felt like home the way you did.
I wanted to drive to your house. To tell you how much I miss you. How I tried to replace you so that I wouldn't have to deal with you rejecting me. How the thought of you kissing somebody else kills me, and how me kissing somebody else made me physically sick. How afraid I am of losing you.
But instead I came home. I went to bed. And I woke up this morning,Thanksgiving morning. And all I can think of now is how grateful I am for you. For everything you've shown me. And for the person I became while knowing you. For allowing me to see love in your eyes, even if it was only for that brief moment. And for introducing me to what home feels like. I'd been searching for that my entire life.
I texted you Happy Thanksigivng. When I really wanted to say I miss you.
P.s. I know we are through. I think it took a lot of bravery for you to tell me that. I know you can't force something that's not there, even if you wanted it to be. I am trying really hard to not close myself off, even though my pride and heart both desperately want me to.
So tonight, I drove to the lake, and I sat there and cried for awhile. I'm confused and find it difficult to comprehend how I let myself feel so deeply for you when I know you didn't feel the same. Except deep down, I thought you would realize that you did. But that is a me problem, not a you one. And I promise not to speak about feelings or heartbreak with you anymore. I just wanted you to read this so you could know the whole truth. That even though I know you didn't treat me how you should have, even though I knew you didn't feel how I felt in the end, and even though I wanted to delete you, I can't. Because you were put in my life for a reason. And it doesn't make sense that I uncahracteristically let you in, only to shut you out because we don't work as a couple. We are best friends. You know me completely. I know you. And I don't want to stop knowing you just because I have to stop loving you. So, before I stop showing my emotions and switch off into friend mode, I want to say:
I sincerely hope you find who and what you are looking for. I hope you can eventually reach a point in your life where you feel worthy and deserving of the love that you crave. Because you do deserve it. More than anybody I've ever met. And while it will sting when you do find her, I hope our friendship lasts long enough for me to be able to see that guy, the one who loves himself enough to be able to love somebody else.